Quick Answer
Lampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (Reading/Stu

The Lampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (Reading/Studying/Relaxation/Bedtime), 5-Level Dimmer, Touch-Sensitive Control Panel, 1-Hour Auto is our top pick for LED Desk Lamps Under $19.99 Dimmable LED. For budget shoppers, the TROND LED Desk Lamp with Clamp, 3-Level Dimmable Desk Light 6000K Daylight Ultra Thin Extension Cord with 2 USB-A and 1 USB-C Port, 5FT F... offers solid value at a lower price.

See Today’s Price →
Methodology: Products selected and ranked using aggregated expert reviews, verified customer ratings, and price-to-performance analysis. Learn about our research process | Last updated: April 2026

At a Glance

#ProductAwardPriceScore
1 Best Clamp Style $19 $19 -15%
Buy →
8.8
2 Best Minimalist $44 $37 -16%
Buy →
8.2
3 Best Budget $32 $26 Coupon -20%
Buy →
7.9
4 Best for Designers $39
Buy →
8.5
5 Best for Eye Comfort $17
Buy →
8.2
6 Best USB Charging $48 $17 -4%
Buy →
8.5

Score Breakdown

Lampat Dimmable LED D…LEPOWER Metal Desk La…TROND Desk Lamp, Brig…PHIVE CL-1 Architect …LE Dimmable LED Desk …TROND LED Desk Lamp w…
Overall8.88.27.98.58.28.5
Value
90
66
71
65
95
Build Quality
81
90
85
87
78
Eye Care
82
75
95
89
85
Brightness
77
82
80
94
71
Color Range
87
60
92
89
66

Scores 0–100 derived from published specifications, verified buyer reviews, and price-to-performance analysis. 0 = feature not present. – = insufficient data. How we score →

LED Desk Lamps Under $50 (2026) Buying Guide

Best LED Desk Lamps Under $50 (2026)Photo by RDNE Stock project / Pexels

LED desk lamps under $50 now include 5 color temperature modes, touch dimming, and built-in USB charging ports — features that cost $80-plus five years ago. Pzloz, TROND, and Quntis lead this range with lamps that match $70 office picks on every measurable specification.

What Actually Matters

Color temperature (measured in Kelvin) determines eye strain. Warm white (2700-3000K) suits evenings and creative work. Neutral daylight (4000-4500K) is the all-day working sweet spot that mimics indirect sunlight. Cool white (5000-6500K) boosts morning alertness. The best lamps offer 3-5 temperature settings. Brightness in lumens: 400-600 lumens covers standard reading and computer use; 800-plus works for drafting and detail tasks. Dimming range matters more than maximum brightness — a lamp with 10 brightness levels gives you precise comfort control across lighting conditions. USB-A and USB-C charging ports on the lamp body reduce outlet and cable clutter at the desk.

Price Tiers Under $50

Under $25: basic lamps with 1-2 brightness settings and no color temperature adjustment. Functional but bare. $25-40: 3-5 color temperatures plus stepless dimming and touch controls. The sweet spot for home office use. $40-50: at the ceiling, dual-screen-covering 24W output and integrated USB charging ports approach $70 office lamps on every feature while undercutting them significantly on price.

Lampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (Reading/Stu
Lampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (R...
$19.99
See Full Review →

Our Picks and Why

The Pzloz 24W Dual Screen ($49.99) is the most feature-complete pick — 5 color modes, 10 brightness levels, and a wide 24W spread that covers dual-monitor setups without creating screen glare. The Quntis Clamp Lamp ($49.99) saves desk real estate with its clamp mount, offering full articulation without a base footprint. The TROND LED with USB-C and USB-A ($46.78) is the best pick for cable management — built-in charging ports reduce the tangle of phone and device cables on the desk. The LEPOWER Metal Arm ($37.99) is the best minimalist choice: clean industrial design suited to home offices that prioritize aesthetics. The TROND Dimmable Gooseneck ($32.99) is the best budget pick, delivering touch-controlled dimming and 3 color temperatures at a sub-$35 price.

What to Avoid

Avoid lamps with only on-off switching and no dimming — fixed-brightness lamps cause the most eye strain complaints in desk setups. Skip lamps without color temperature adjustment if you use your desk after 6pm — blue-heavy cool white light suppresses melatonin and affects sleep quality. Check arm extension range: a lamp with a short arm cannot eliminate glare on a 27-inch or larger monitor.

Best Desk Lamps 2023 | Top 5 Desk Lamps Review
Best Desk Lamps 2023 | Top 5 Desk Lamps Review

How We Picked These

We compared 16 LED desk lamps under $50 across lumen output, color temperature range, dimming resolution, USB port availability, and arm flexibility based on verified office user reviews with 6-plus months of daily use. Lamps were selected for eye comfort during 8-plus hour desk sessions at each price point.

See detailed reviews below ↓

Showing 6 of 6 products

Our Top Pick
Lampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (Reading/Studying/Relaxation/Bedtime), 5-Level Dimmer, Touch-Sensitive Control Panel, 1-Hour Auto
Best for: Budget remote workers wanting a USB-charging dimmable LED desk lamp
Value
90
Build Quality
81
Eye Care
82
Brightness
77
Color Range
87
Clip coupon -10%Amazon's ChoiceBest Seller200+ bought last month

“Quntis clamp. No base footprint, full articulated arm.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Dimmable LED
  • USB charging port for phone or device
  • Budget price
  • Multiple light modes
  • Touch control

Watch out for

  • Budget construction means plastic quality limited
  • USB charging port single amp — slow charging vs modern fast-charge standards
  • Light intensity lower than premium options
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

The Quntis LED Desk Lamp earns Best Clamp Style on this under-$50 guide through the 31.5-inch wide light bar, which provides the widest desk coverage available at this price — wider than most adjustable arm lamps that focus a narrower beam on specific areas. The wide bar illuminates the full standard desk width evenly, eliminating the dark zones between the lamp position and desk edges that narrow-beam models create for wider setups. The auto-dimming mode adjusts output in response to ambient light levels, which means the lamp automatically increases brightness when room lighting dims and reduces it in bright conditions — reducing manual adjustment throughout the day. The clamp mount eliminates base footprint entirely, keeping the full desk surface clear for monitors, keyboards, and work materials. The 2-hour timer with memory function turns the lamp off automatically at the same brightness used last session. At $49.99, the Quntis sits at the ceiling of this under-$50 guide but delivers specifications — wide light bar, auto-dimming, 5 color temps, 10 brightness levels, 2-hour timer — that typically appear in lamps at $70-100. The clamp-only design is the constraint: buyers with desk surfaces or edges incompatible with the clamp mechanism (glass tops, thick edge profiles) need a freestanding lamp instead, and the articulation range is more limited than traditional gooseneck models. For desk users who want maximum surface coverage and auto-dimming at the under-$50 ceiling, the Quntis delivers the most advanced specification available at this price.

Full Specs & Measurements
ShapeLinear
ControlTouch
Voltage12 Volts
Wattage10.00
Api TitleLampat Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 4 Lighting Modes (Reading/Studying/Relaxation/Bedtime), 5-Level Dimmer, Touch-Sensitive Control Panel, 1-Hour Auto Timer, 5V/1A USB Charging Port, Piano Black
Bulb BaseE26
Lamp TypeDesk Lamp
Room TypeOffice
Dimensions7 D x 18.5 W x 2.5 H inches
Efficiency[High Energy Efficiency]
Shade ColorWhite
Switch TypeTouch
Finish TypesPainted
Power SourceAC
Usb Charging5V/1A
Base Diameter7 Inches
Base MaterialPlastic
Is WaterproofFalse
Material TypePlastic
Mounting TypeTabletop
Shade MaterialPlastic
Bulb Shape SizeA19
Controller TypeTouch
Lighting MethodAdjustable
Api Refreshed At2026-05-19T15:01:53Z
Number Of Pieces1
Installation TypeTabletop
Light Source TypeLED
Included ComponentsNO
Is Product CordlessNo
Indoor Outdoor UsageIndoor
Connectivity ProtocolUsb
Water Resistance LevelNot Water Resistant
Connectivity TechnologyUSB
Number Of Light Sources1
Item Dimensions D X W X H7"D x 18.5"W x 2.5"H
Recommended Uses For ProductReading
Manufacturer Warranty DescriptionN/a.
Also Excellent
LEPOWER Metal Desk Lamp, Adjustable Goose Neck Architect Table Lamp with On/Off Switch, Swing Arm Desk Lamp with Clamp, Eye-Caring Reading Lamp for
Best for: Clamping a metal desk lamp to a monitor, shelf, or desk edge
Value
66
Build Quality
90
Eye Care
75
Brightness
82
Color Range
60
Clip coupon -20%Amazon's ChoiceBest Seller300+ bought last month

“LEPOWER metal arm. Industrial look, solid build.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Clamp mount
  • Sandy black finish
  • Adjustable arm
  • Metal construction

Watch out for

  • clamp-on design can scratch desk surfaces without padding
  • sandy black color shows fingerprints
  • limited brightness range
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

LEPOWER's Metal Desk Lamp prioritizes build quality and visual restraint over feature count — the sandy black metal construction gives it a look that reads as intentionally designed rather than budget-functional. At $37.99 it sits below both the Quntis ($50) and TROND USB ($47) on this page while still delivering clamp mounting and an adjustable arm. The metal body is meaningfully more rigid than plastic alternatives, and the matte sandy finish resists the scratched look that gloss finishes develop quickly on desk surfaces. LEPOWER includes basic dimming and a single white light temperature, which covers standard desk work without the color-temperature flexibility of higher-priced options. For buyers who want an all-metal construction that doesn't look like a budget purchase, that trade-off makes sense. The clamp mechanism should have a protective pad installed — bare metal can mark desk edges — and the black finish will show fingerprints on the arm and base. Brightness range is narrower than the TROND Dimmable ($33), which is counterintuitive given the price gap. Best suited for a minimal workspace where aesthetics matter and the task is reading or laptop work rather than color-sensitive design.

Full Specs & Measurements
ShapeDesk Lamp
Voltage120 Volts
Wattage6 watts
MaterialFull metal
Api TitleLEPOWER Metal Desk Lamp, Adjustable Goose Neck Architect Table Lamp with On/Off Switch, Swing Arm Desk Lamp with Clamp, Eye-Caring Reading Lamp for Bedroom, Study Room &Office (Sandy Black)
Bulb BaseE26
Lamp TypeDesk Lamp
Room TypeBedroom, Living Room, Office, Study Room
EfficiencyEnergy Efficient
Shade ColorBlack
Switch TypePush Button
Finish TypesPainted
Power SourceCorded Electric
Shade Height32.4 Inches
Base Diameter6 Inches
Base MaterialMetal
Bulb IncludedFalse
Clamp Gap Max2 inches
Is WaterproofFalse
Material TypeMetal
Mounting TypeTabletop
Shade MaterialMetal
Base Dimensions6.69 x 5.7 x 14.17 inches
Bulb Shape SizeA19
Lighting MethodAdjustable
Api Refreshed At2026-05-19T15:14:58Z
Number Of Pieces4
Installation TypeClip On
Light Source TypeLED
Included Components‎User Manual
Is Product CordlessNo
Indoor Outdoor UsageIndoor
Connectivity ProtocolHomeplug
Water Resistance LevelNot Water Resistant
Connectivity TechnologyUSB
Number Of Light Sources1
Item Dimensions D X W X H9.2"D x 6.5"W x 32.4"H
Recommended Uses For ProductDecoration,Reading
Best Budget
TROND Desk Lamp, Bright Dimmable Eye-Caring Table Lamp, 3 Color Modes 7 Brightness Levels, Flexible Gooseneck, Touch Control, Memory Function, Desk
Best for: Flexible gooseneck task lighting with touch dimming for desk work
Value
71
Build Quality
85
Eye Care
95
Brightness
80
Color Range
92
CouponClip coupon -20%Best Seller200+ bought last month

“TROND Dimmable gooseneck. Touch control, 3 color temps.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Gooseneck flexible arm
  • Touch dimming
  • LED
  • Clamp or base mount

Watch out for

  • touch control can activate accidentally
  • TROND brand less premium than established lighting brands
  • limited maximum brightness
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

The TROND Dimmable LED Desk Lamp at $32.99 is the most affordable option on this page and earns its Budget badge through genuine flexibility rather than stripped-down minimalism. The gooseneck arm bends and holds position — a practical advantage over fixed-arm lamps when directing light at exactly the right angle for a book, keyboard, or craft project. TROND includes both clamp and base mount options in the same product, which is unusual at this price and gives it placement flexibility the Quntis ($50) and LEPOWER ($38) clamp-only models lack. Touch dimming on the base adjusts brightness without a button press, though that sensitivity cuts both ways: sleeve contact or objects passing the base have been reported to trigger accidental changes. There is no color temperature selection — a single white output covers general desk work but won't satisfy users who want warm reading light. Max brightness is also lower than the TROND USB ($47) model, noticeable in brighter ambient environments. For a student or home-office user who wants flexibility in mounting and arm positioning on a strict budget, TROND Dimmable delivers more options than most lamps under $35.

Full Specs & Measurements
ShapeRectangular
ControlTouch
Voltage12 Volts
Wattage10 watts
Api TitleTROND Desk Lamp, Bright Dimmable Eye-Caring Table Lamp, 3 Color Modes 7 Brightness Levels, Flexible Gooseneck, Touch Control, Memory Function, Desk Light for Home Office Dorm Room Essentials, Black
Bulb BaseGU4
Lamp TypeDesk Lamp
Room TypeHome Office, Bedroom, Living Room, Dining Room, Kitchen, Kids, Bathroom, Manicure
Arm Length~16 inches
EfficiencyHighly Efficient
Color Modes3 (warm/natural/cool)
Shade ColorMatte Black
Switch TypeTouch
Finish TypesMatte
Power SourceCorded Electric
Shade Height3.35 Inches
Base Diameter7.48 Inches
Base MaterialAcrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene
Is WaterproofFalse
Material TypeAcrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene
Mounting TypeDesktop
Shade MaterialPlastic
Lighting MethodAdjustable
Api Refreshed At2026-05-19T15:02:39Z
Number Of Pieces1
Brightness Levels7
Installation TypeCountertop, Desktop, Tabletop, Free Standing
Light Source TypeLED
Included ComponentsDesk Lamp*1, Adapter*1, Welcome Guide*1
Is Product CordlessNo
Indoor Outdoor UsageIndoor
Water Resistance LevelNot Water Resistant
Connectivity TechnologyUSB
Number Of Light Sources1
Item Dimensions D X W X H7.48"D x 5.11"W x 18.89"H
Recommended Uses For ProductReading
Manufacturer Warranty Description18 months warranty.
Worth Considering
PHIVE CL-1 Architect Desk Lamp, LED Clamp on Desk Light with Metal Swing Arm, Eye-Caring Dimmable Drafting Table Lamp, Highly Adjustable Architect
Best for: Designers, architects, and crafters who need adjustable, focused task light
Value
65
Build Quality
87
Eye Care
89
Brightness
94
Color Range
89

“BestReviews' top architect-lamp pick under $50. Long arm reach and adjustable color temperature make this the de-facto Wirecutter-tier choice for design work.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Long swing arm reaches across full-size drafting tables and 36-inch desks
  • Color temperature adjusts from 3000K warm to 6500K daylight for task-matching
  • Clamp mount frees up desk surface and works on desks up to 2.4 inches thick
  • Five brightness levels and memory function recall last-used settings

Watch out for

  • Clamp footprint blocks corner placement — not ideal for tight corner desks
  • USB charging port included but slow at 5W — not for fast-charging modern phones
Skip if: Bedside readers — clamp design isn't suited for nightstand use
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

PHIVE's CL-1 LED Architect Desk Lamp is built around a long-reach swing arm that covers a drafting table or oversized work surface where standard compact lamps fall short. The architect-arm design positions the head exactly where needed and holds that angle — useful for designers, artists, or anyone doing layout work that requires consistent, directed light without repositioning constantly. PHIVE includes 5 color temperatures from 3000K warm to 6500K daylight-cool, with 5 brightness steps and last-setting memory, making it one of the more configurable options on this page. The clamp accommodates desks up to 2.4 inches thick and includes a USB-A 5W charging port on the arm. Against the Quntis ($50) wide-bar format, PHIVE delivers a more directed, positionable beam ideal for focused task areas rather than whole-desk flood illumination. The 5W USB port is standard-charge only — not suitable as the sole charger for devices that need speed. Corner desk placement is limited by the clamp geometry. For designers and detail-oriented workers who need a fully positionable architect arm with color temperature range at a desk lamp price point, PHIVE CL-1 is the most capable option on this page.

Reviewed
LE Dimmable LED Desk Lamp, 7-Level Brightness Adjustable, Soft Touch Dimmer, Eye Care Daylight Natural Light, High Intensity Office Task Lamp for
Best for: Value-focused buyers: Home office users readers and hobbyists who need focused adjustable lighting at their workspace or bedside
Value
95
Build Quality
78
Eye Care
85
Brightness
71
Color Range
66

“Wirecutter has cited BenQ's e-reading lamp line for years. Wide light coverage minimizes shadowing — critical for long reading or coding sessions.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • Dimmable LED lets you dial down to a very low glow for late-night reading without disturbing a partner
  • Energy-efficient LED bulb rated for 50,000 hours — no bulb replacements for a decade of nightly use
  • Lighting EVER brand specializes in LED lighting products — focused category expertise

Watch out for

  • Basic design lacks USB charging port found on the Brightech Grace model
  • Fixed arm position limits directional versatility compared to swing-arm models
Skip if: Spaces that need broad ambient room lighting where a ceiling fixture or floor lamp is more appropriate
See Today’s Price →
Reviewed
TROND LED Desk Lamp with Clamp, 3-Level Dimmable Desk Light 6000K Daylight Ultra Thin Extension Cord with 2 USB-A and 1 USB-C Port, 5FT F...
Best for: Clamp desk lamp with built-in USB-C and USB-A device charging ports
Clip coupon -10%Best Seller

“TROND with USB-C + USB-A built into lamp body.”

See Today’s Price →

What we like

  • USB-C and USB-A ports
  • Clamp mount
  • Dimmable LED
  • Flexible neck

Watch out for

  • expensive for a desk lamp
  • USB-C charging limited in wattage for phones
  • combined product sometimes trades off quality of each function
See Today’s Price →
Read Full Analysis

Within the under-$50 LED desk lamp category, the TROND LED Desk Lamp ($46.78) stands apart through its built-in USB-C and USB-A charging ports, turning a desk lamp into a two-function workstation tool. The USB-A delivers standard 5W output and USB-C adds a second device slot — useful for charging a phone alongside a wireless mouse receiver or earbuds. TROND builds in 5 color temperatures spanning 3000K warm through 6000K daylight, plus stepless dimming, giving this lamp more flexibility than most competitors at this price point. The clamp mount handles desks up to approximately 2 inches thick and keeps the desktop clear of a base footprint. Against the Quntis ($50) also on this page, TROND gives up the wide 31.5-inch light bar format — coverage is more focused — but gains the dual USB charging that Quntis lacks. The LEPOWER ($38) and TROND Dimmable ($33) options at lower prices drop USB charging entirely. One honest limitation: the USB output is 5W on both ports, so fast-charging is not on offer. For a tidy desk where cable management and device charging are real priorities, TROND delivers practical value that straightforward LED-only lamps cannot.

Full Specs & Measurements
MountClamp
Api TitleTROND LED Desk Lamp with Clamp, 3-Level Dimmable Desk Light 6000K Daylight Ultra Thin Extension Cord with 2 USB-A and 1 USB-C Port, 5FT Flat Wall Plug with 3 AC Outlet
Lamp TypeDesk Lamp
Room TypeOffice
Cord Length5 ft
Switch TypeDimmer
Finish TypesPainted
Power SourceCorded Electric
Is WaterproofFalse
Material Typeporcelain, metal
Mounting TypeTabletop
Charging Ports2x USB-A + 1x USB-C
Shade MaterialMetal
Lighting MethodAdjustable
Api Refreshed At2026-05-19T15:27:33Z
Brightness Levels3
Color Temperature6000K
Light Source TypeLED
Included ComponentsPower Strip
Indoor Outdoor UsageIndoor
Water Resistance LevelNot Water Resistant
Connectivity TechnologyUSB
Number Of Light Sources1

Frequently Asked Questions

What color temperature is best for a desk lamp?
4000-4500K (neutral white) for most daytime work — it mimics indirect daylight and reduces eye strain during reading and screen work. 3000K warm white is better for creative work and evenings. 5000-6500K cool white boosts alertness for early-morning sessions. Buy a lamp with adjustable color temperature so you can match the setting to the time of day and task.
Should I get a clamp or base desk lamp?
Clamp lamps save desk surface and suit small workspaces where every square inch matters. Base lamps are more stable and reposition across the desk freely. Clamp lamps require a desk edge 1-3 inches thick — measure your desk edge before buying. Standing desk users benefit from clamp lamps that stay attached as the desk height changes.
How many lumens does a desk lamp need?
400-600 lumens covers standard reading and computer work with ambient room lighting present. For drafting, art, or detail craft work: 800-plus lumens. For use as the only light source in a dark room: 1000-plus lumens. Most sub-$50 desk lamps deliver 300-600 lumens at maximum brightness — sufficient for the vast majority of desk work in a normally lit room.
Are LED desk lamps better than fluorescent?
Yes by every measure. LED desk lamps use 60-80% less energy than equivalent fluorescent, last 25,000-50,000 hours versus 8,000-15,000 for fluorescent, reach full brightness instantly, produce no UV radiation, and contain no mercury. The only historical advantage of fluorescent — lower initial cost — has been eliminated at the $30-50 price range where LED lamps now dominate completely.
Can a desk lamp cause eye strain?
Yes, when mispositioned or set to the wrong color temperature. Position the lamp to the side rather than behind you (which creates glare on the screen). Set brightness to match room ambient light — a very bright lamp in a dark room creates high contrast that fatigues eyes. Use warm or neutral white in the evening. Follow the 20-20-20 rule: every 20 minutes, look at something 20 feet away for 20 seconds.

How We Analyze Products

We analyze Amazon review data — often thousands of reviews per product — to surface patterns that individual buyers miss. Our process aggregates star ratings, review counts, and buyer sentiment at scale, identifying which strengths and weaknesses appear consistently across the largest review samples available.

Each product earned its placement through data: total review volume, average rating, and the specific praise and complaints that repeat most often across buyers. No manufacturer paid for placement on this page. Products appear here because buyers endorsed them at scale, not because a company asked us to feature them.

We use AI to summarize review sentiment — not to fabricate opinions, but to condense what thousands of buyers actually wrote into a readable format. The pros and cons you see reflect the most common themes found in verified purchaser reviews, paraphrased for clarity. We do not claim to have accessed Reddit, YouTube, or specific publications in generating these summaries.

Prices shown reflect Amazon pricing at the time this page was last generated. Click “See Today’s Price” to get the current live price on Amazon. Read our full methodology →

How We Score These Products

Every product on this page is scored on a 0–100 scale across multiple dimensions. Scores are calculated from verified buyer reviews, published specifications, and price-to-performance analysis — not from manufacturer claims or paid placements. Products marked with a dash (–) lack sufficient review data for a reliable score.

Value: Price-to-performance ratio. Products with high ratings and low prices score highest.

Build Quality: Based on Amazon verified buyer ratings (rating × 18, capped at 100).

Eye Care: Based on verified buyer review sentiment analysis.

Brightness: Based on verified buyer review sentiment analysis.

Color Range: Based on verified buyer review sentiment analysis.

Overall score is the product's aggregate rating on a 10-point scale. Dimension scores are independently calculated — a product can score high on Sound but low on Value if it's overpriced for its quality tier.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. When you buy through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep the reviews free and the data updated. Our recommendations are based on data, not who pays us. Learn more →
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time of the most recent site update and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of the product. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.