Best Online Gold & Silver Dealers 2026: Where to Buy Precious Metals
Silver Gold Bull is the best starting choice for North American buyers — competitive premiums, transparent pricing, and a legitimate buyback program. APMEX and JM Bullion are consistently competitive for the lowest premiums on silver. For gold, premium differences between major dealers are small (1-2%) — choose on payment method, shipping cost, and buyback policy.
At a Glance
Online Gold & Silver Dealers Buying Guide
Photo by merwak. raw / PexelsHow we evaluated these. We compared online gold and silver dealers across spot price premium (%), buyback spread, coin/bar product selection, shipping insurance, storage options, and BBB/TrustPilot ratings, cross-referencing CPM Group dealer data, JM Bullion pricing benchmarks, and verified customer reviews. Rates as of April 2026. This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice.
Some products featured are from partners who compensate us, which may influence which products we write about. This does not affect our evaluations. Our opinions are our own. Learn more.
Quick Verdict: Our top pick is Silver Gold Bull — transparent live pricing, strong buyback program, and competitive premiums for North American buyers. APMEX and JM Bullion are equally strong for comparison shopping.
<Top Pick: Silver Gold Bull
Silver Gold Bull is a well-established North American precious metals dealer with transparent live pricing, a legitimate buyback program, and competitive premiums across silver rounds, bars, and gold coins. For first-time buyers, Silver Gold Bull's interface makes pricing and product differences easy to understand. APMEX and JM Bullion are equally reputable and worth price-comparing on any order — the major dealers are often within $0.50–$1.00/oz of each other on silver and $10–$30/oz on gold. Premium differences matter most on large orders; for small purchases, choose based on shipping cost and payment method.
How to Compare Precious Metals Dealers
Four factors determine the real cost of buying from any dealer:
- Premium over spot: The markup above the current spot price (market price per troy ounce). Lower premiums mean lower total cost. Compare premiums — not just listed prices — since spot prices change throughout the day.
- Payment method discount: Most dealers offer 1–4% lower prices for check, wire transfer, or cryptocurrency vs. credit card. On a $1,000 order, this discount often exceeds credit card rewards earned.
- Shipping cost: Flat-rate shipping ($9.95–$19.95) vs. free shipping thresholds ($99–$199) significantly affect small orders. Factor shipping into per-ounce cost.
- Buyback policy: Will the dealer buy back your metals at competitive prices? Silver Gold Bull, APMEX, and JM Bullion all have buyback programs. Verify current buyback spreads before purchasing — the difference between buy price and buyback price is your true round-trip cost.
Understanding Premiums Over Spot
Typical premiums as of early 2026 (verify current premiums at each dealer — these fluctuate with supply and demand):
- Generic silver rounds (1 oz): $2–4 over spot (~7–13%)
- American Silver Eagle (government mint): $5–8 over spot (~17–25%) — highest liquidity, recognized everywhere
- Silver bars (10 oz+): $1–2 over spot per oz (~3–7%) — most cost-efficient for accumulating silver
- American Gold Eagle (1 oz): $75–150 over spot (~3–6%)
- 1 oz gold bar: $50–100 over spot (~2–4%) — lower premium than coins, slightly less liquid
- 1/10 oz gold coins: Much higher percentage premium — buy 1 oz denominations when possible for better value
Spot price benchmarks as of early 2026: silver approximately $30–32/oz, gold approximately $2,600–2,800/oz. Verify real-time spot at kitco.com before any purchase.
Who Each Dealer Is Best For
- Silver Gold Bull: North American buyers who want transparent pricing, easy product navigation, and a reliable buyback option
- APMEX: Buyers who want the largest selection, including rare coins, collectibles, and fractional gold — industry's largest inventory
- JM Bullion: Price-conscious buyers — JM Bullion is consistently competitive on premiums and offers free shipping on orders over a set threshold
- SD Bullion: Budget-focused buyers looking for some of the lowest premiums on generic silver rounds and bars, particularly for larger orders
For first-time buyers: start with 1 oz silver rounds from any of the above to understand the buying process before committing to gold. Government-mint coins (American Eagle, Canadian Maple Leaf) have the highest liquidity but cost more per ounce than generic rounds.
What to Watch Out For
- Credit card surcharges. Most dealers add 3–4% for credit card purchases. This typically exceeds any rewards earned. Use check, wire, or ACH where possible for large orders.
- Tax on capital gains. In the US, precious metals are taxed as collectibles — gains above your cost basis are subject to up to 28% federal tax when you sell, not the lower long-term capital gains rate. Keep purchase records (date, price, quantity) for every transaction.
- Storage matters. Precious metals at home require a fireproof safe bolted in place. Bank safe deposit boxes are not FDIC insured and are inaccessible during bank closures. Segregated allocated storage through a dealer costs 0.12–0.5% per year and provides third-party documentation of ownership.
- Verify authenticity. Stick to established dealers (APMEX, JM Bullion, Silver Gold Bull, SD Bullion) for new purchases. Avoid marketplace sellers on eBay or Facebook for investment-grade metals — counterfeits exist and are difficult to detect without professional testing.
How to Buy Precious Metals Online
- Check real-time spot price at kitco.com before shopping — dealers update prices throughout the day
- Calculate per-ounce total cost: spot price + premium + (shipping ÷ ounces purchased)
- Compare at least two dealers on the same product — JM Bullion and SD Bullion often have the lowest premiums on generic silver
- Choose payment method: check/wire saves 1–4% vs. credit card on large orders
- Record your purchase: date, product, quantity, price paid — you'll need this when you sell
- Plan storage before delivery — have a secure location ready before your package arrives
For tools to track your full portfolio including precious metals holdings, our Best Personal Finance and Credit Tools 2026 covers net worth trackers and investment dashboards that handle alternative assets. For the broader context of where gold and silver fit in a financial plan, How to Budget: The Simplest System That Actually Works covers the savings and investment allocation decisions that typically precede a metals purchase. For storing value while earning rewards, Best Rewards Credit Cards of 2026 covers cards worth using to buy from these dealers (many offer purchase rewards on bullion
This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Consult a licensed financial advisor for guidance specific to your situation.
Silver Gold Bull
“Transparent live pricing, strong buyback program, North American operations.”
What we like
- Transparent live pricing with premiums shown directly on product pages
- Competitive premiums on silver rounds, bars, and common gold products
- Strong buyback program — sell back at near-spot prices
- US and Canada operations — faster shipping than international-only dealers
- Established reputation with strong Trustpilot ratings and BBB accreditation
Watch out for
- Precious metals are a low-margin business — compare live prices on each order rather than assuming loyalty pricing
- Premium prices on some popular coins slightly higher than lowest-cost competitors
- Credit card purchases carry a surcharge (use check/wire for best pricing)
Rates as of April 16, 2026. Terms apply. Verify on issuer site.
APMEX (American Precious Metals Exchange)
“Largest US dealer, 20,000+ products, gold standard for secondary market liquidity.”
What we like
- Largest selection of any US precious metals dealer — 20,000+ products
- Highly recognized brand — APMEX coins and bars sell easily on secondary market
- Excellent pricing on popular high-volume products
- Storage program, IRA-eligible products, and institutional buying options
- 75,000+ customer reviews with consistently high ratings
Watch out for
- Can be overwhelming for first-time buyers — too many product options
- Premium pricing on some niche products; shop specific items against competitors
- Credit card surcharge of 4% on most purchases
Rates as of April 16, 2026. Terms apply. Verify on issuer site.
JM Bullion
“Lowest premiums on silver rounds and bars, free shipping over $199, no credit card surcharge.”
What we like
- Consistently among the lowest premiums on silver rounds, silver bars, and gold bars
- Free shipping on all orders over $199
- 0% credit card surcharge (absorbed into pricing) — no surprise surcharges at checkout
- Clean, easy-to-navigate website with straightforward buying process
- Strong reviews and established reputation since 2011
Watch out for
- Smaller selection than APMEX — focused on popular products, not niche collectibles
- 0% credit card fee is partially offset in base pricing — use check/wire for lowest cost
- Less brand recognition in secondary market vs. APMEX products
Rates as of April 16, 2026. Terms apply. Verify on issuer site.
SD Bullion
“Best for bulk silver volume purchases. Price match guarantee, very competitive on monster boxes.”
What we like
- Among the lowest premiums on monster boxes (500 oz) and bulk silver purchases
- Price match guarantee — will match competitor prices
- Wider free shipping threshold but strong for large orders
- Good selection of junk silver (90% US coins) at low premiums
Watch out for
- Less polished website and checkout experience than APMEX or JM Bullion
- Customer service reviews more mixed than larger competitors
- Better suited for experienced buyers; may confuse first-time buyers
Rates as of April 16, 2026. Terms apply. Verify on issuer site.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is buying gold and silver online safe?
What's the minimum I should buy to make it worthwhile?
American Silver Eagles vs. generic silver rounds — which should I buy?
How do I sell precious metals I bought online?
Should I buy gold or silver?
How We Evaluate Financial Products
We compare financial products based on objective criteria: annual fees, APR ranges, rewards rates, sign-up bonuses, and key perks. We do not factor in issuer relationships or compensation when determining rankings. Products are ranked based on overall value for the target use case described on this page.
Rates and terms change frequently. We update these pages regularly, but always verify current rates directly on the issuer’s website before applying. APR ranges shown reflect the full possible range — your actual rate depends on your creditworthiness.
This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. We compare products; we do not advise on which product is right for your personal financial situation. Read our full methodology →