Brother vs HP Laser Printer 2026: Which Office Printer Wins?

The Brother HL-L2370DW is Brother's compact monochrome laser printer—single-function print-only without scan, copy, or fax, in Brother's most compact and affordable laser form factor at $120–150. The HL-L2370DW's single-function focus produces the highest printing speed in Brother's entry lineup (36 pages per minute) without the mechanical complexity and added size of the all-in-one configuration. For households or small offices that have separate scanning capability (smartphone scanning apps, dedicated scanner) and primarily need fast, reliable monochrome document printing, the single-function laser is the minimum-cost approach to laser print quality. The 2,600-page standard toner delivers solid per-cartridge economics even at the entry tier. Against HP LaserJet MFP models on this page, Brother HL-L2370DW is the print-only simplicity option at the lowest price point in the laser printer comparison. The all-in-one models (both Brother and HP) cost $50–150 more for the added scan/copy functionality that single-function printers don't include.

The Brother MFC-L2750DW is Brother's feature-complete monochrome all-in-one—print, copy, scan, fax with automatic document feeder, duplex printing (both sides automatically), and wireless/Ethernet networking. At $220–280, the MFC-L2750DW covers small office and home office requirements with the 4-in-1 functionality at the mid-range monochrome tier. Brother's all-in-one reputation centers on reliability and low total cost of ownership—the high-yield toner cartridges (3,000-page standard, up to 8,000-page high-yield replacement toner) reduce per-page costs significantly compared to lower-yield entry printers. The 50-page automatic document feeder handles multi-page scan and copy jobs without manual page-by-page feeding. Against HP laser printers on this comparison page, Brother's toner cost advantage and build durability are the primary differentiators. Brother's higher-yield cartridges and lower cartridge pricing provide lower per-page printing costs over the printer's lifetime. HP's Smart app integration and Instant Ink subscription (for users who prefer predictable monthly costs) are HP's alternative to Brother's individual cartridge approach.

The HP LaserJet MFP M234dwe is HP's entry-level wireless monochrome all-in-one—print, copy, scan with HP Smart app integration and HP Instant Ink compatibility for the subscription printing model at $150–180. The M234dwe's HP+ smart features require HP Instant Ink subscription for full functionality, positioning it as the entry point for HP's subscription printing ecosystem. HP Instant Ink pricing ($0.10–0.30/page by plan, prepaid monthly) can reduce per-page costs for low-volume users who print infrequently—the plan-based model spreads ink costs across time rather than per-cartridge purchase. For offices or households that print under 50 pages per month, the Instant Ink small-plan pricing can be cost-efficient. Against Brother MFC-L2750DW on this page, HP M234dwe's entry price and Instant Ink subscription model contrast with Brother's higher upfront investment and pay-per-cartridge approach. For buyers who prefer predictable monthly printing costs and print low volumes, HP's subscription model may suit. For high-volume users, Brother's high-yield cartridges typically provide lower per-page costs.

The HP Color LaserJet Pro M255dw is HP's wireless color laser printer—the single-function color laser at $230–300 that provides the color output that Brother's monochrome all-in-one and HP's monochrome LaserJets don't offer. Color laser printing provides cost-efficient color output at per-page costs significantly lower than color inkjet ($0.10–0.15/page versus $0.20–0.30/page for inkjets at typical use). The M255dw's 22 pages-per-minute speed handles small office color document printing without the delay of inkjet warm-up periods that laser printers eliminate. The duplex printing enables automatic double-sided color output for cost-saving on color presentations and documents. Against Brother MFC-L2750DW monochrome all-in-one on this page, HP M255dw provides color capability at the cost of the scan, copy, and fax functions that the Brother all-in-one includes. For color-critical output needs (marketing materials, reports with charts, customer-facing documents), HP M255dw's color printing is the specific capability that monochrome printers can't provide.